>The only two certainties in life are supposed to be death and taxes. Did you know that municipal bonds are designed for receiving tax-free income? Before we get bored by the concept of taxes and municipal bonds, let's remember that both fees and taxes have significant impacts to our investment portfolios. Municipal bonds are issued by state and local governments. Each municipal bond is unique. For example, state and local governments might issue a municipal bond in order to build schools, libraries, fire departments, water infrastructure and / or transportation infrastructure. There are also municipal bonds that are general obligation (GO) bonds which do not specify the reason for which they are purposed. Treasury bonds are different because they are issued by the federal government. When investors are paid income from municipal or treasury bonds, the federal government does not tax this income. Not to get tricky, but state and local governments might tax this income. The tax benefit to municipal bond investors is so great that the interest payments (also known as yield or income) are typically less than other bonds. The comparative benefits for investors can be measured by using the tax-equivalent yield. A tax-equivalent yield is a relative metric between investment products after all taxes are considered. Let's look at two generic tax examples, a married couple filing jointly in California and a married couple filing jointly in New York. We are going to isolate as many variables as possible by looking at two state tax structures, and by making some assumptions. We are assuming annual taxable income of $100,000. We are assuming that the municipal bond investment is an ETF and it has not been sold. This means that any price appreciation of the ETF is not included in our tax equivalent yield. We are assuming that all underlying bonds inside the ETF are bought and sold at par value. This means that any potential distribution yield is not included in our tax-equivalent yield. Due to state tax rates, investment products require different levels of yield in CA and NY in order to accomplish the same 3.0% municipal bond yield.
Municipal bond tax-equivalent yieldTax-equivalent yield to CDs and Corporate Bonds - California resident municipal bonds - New York resident municipal bonds - Certificates of deposit (CD) - Corporate bond
California - 3.0% - - - 4.17%
New York - - 3.0% - - -
>Let's continue looking at our ETF choices. We can continue comparing CA and NY while we bring in the concept of high yield municipal bonds. High yield municipal bonds involve more risk of default. These are also known as junk bonds.
California municipal bondsTicker Symbol - ETF Name - Description of strategy - Expense Ratio - Total Assets - 12-Month Yield
CMF - iShares California Municipal Bond - Municipal bonds issued in the State of California, the interest of which is exempt from Federal income tax and not subject to AMT - 0.08% - $3.3 billion - 2.72%
PWZ - Invesco California AMT-Free Municipal Bond - Tax-exempt municipal debt publicly issued by California or any US territory - 0.28% - $706 million - 3.20%
New York municipal bondsTicker Symbol - ETF Name - Description of strategy - Expense Ratio - Total Assets - 12-Month Yield
NYF - iShares New York Municipal Bond - Investment grade municipal bonds issued in the State of New York - 0.25% - $799 million - 2.68%
PZT - Invesco New York AMT-Free Municipal Bond - Investment grade, tax-exempt debt publicly issued by New York or a US territory - 0.28% - $130 million - 2.91%
High yield municipal bondsTicker Symbol - ETF Name - Description of strategy - Expense Ratio - Total Assets - 12-Month Yield
HYD - VanEck High Yield Municipal Bond - Municipal bonds that cover the high yield long term tax-exempt bond market - 0.32% - $3.1 billion - 4.21%
HYMB - SPDR Nuveen Bloomberg High Yield Municipal Bond - High-yield municipal bonds issued by U.S. states, the District of Columbia, U.S. territories and local governments or agencies - 0.35% - $2.8 billion - 4.21%
>ETF investors always need to look under the hood to understand what they are actually owning. We have condensed our examination into three key metrics: the number of holdings, the yield to maturity, and the percentage of the ETF that is investment grade. We have also included an explanation of why each metric is important.
Characteristics of examinationTicker Symbol - Number of holdings - Higher than investment grade (BBB) - Yield to Maturity
Explanation - Bonds can default. Spreading out the risk makes sense - Bonds that are investment grade have a lower default rate - The average yield if all the underlying bonds are held to maturity
CMF - 1,233 - 99.7% - 3.1%
PWZ - 632 - 99.8% - 4.4%
NYF - 646 - 100.0% - 3.3%
PZT - 391 - 99.7% - 4.5%
HYD - 1,519 - 37.7% - 4.9%
HYMB - 1,862 - 36.5% - 4.9%
The two municipal bond ETFs created by Invesco, PWZ representing California and PZT representing New York, are both investment grade. They are also paying similar interest payments to their investors at 4.4% and 4.5%, respectively. These interest payments are closer to the 4.9% high yield category than they are to their investment grade counterparts in the 3.1% to 3.3% range. For this reason, we believe that, with proper tax considerations, municipal bonds are worth a look.