>Many investors have a 401k. Oftentimes, it was the first time investors made investment choices. The 401k plan sponsor chose a limited lineup of investment options for ease and simplicity. There is typically a fund that owns stock in small market capitalization (small cap) companies, alongside large cap stocks, mid cap stocks, international stocks, target-date and bond funds. An allocation to these categories is how most people learn to think about diversification. When we discuss market capitalization, companies are considered small cap if they are worth between $250 million to $2 billion. It is a calculation of the number of shares outstanding multiplied by the share price. It is a representation of the value that market participants are placing on the opportunities for future growth. It is not a calculation of the amount of revenue nor profit that a company makes. Companies are considered large cap if they are worth more than $10 billion. A company that has issued one billion shares needs a share price of $2.01 to exceed the definition of a small cap company. It is common for a company to issue billions of shares of its stock and the exact number varies between companies. It is perfectly reasonable that some investors have different perspectives related to small cap investing. Financial markets are created by a buyer and a seller, two different points of view. The buyer and seller are both expressing an opinion. Some investors make the case that there is more room for growth investing in the stocks of small companies. Some investors make the case that Price/Earnings (P/E) ratios are lower and therefore small cap stocks are less expensive. Some investors make the case that there is more volatility and that, theoretically, this additional risk will eventually be rewarded. We are making the case that this reward is not available to ETF investors. Here are several points to clarify our case.>
• Once a company grows past the $2 billion mark, it is no longer a small cap company and the ETF fund manager must divest from it.
• Great companies attract suitors. Small cap companies are cheaper as a lower-priced acquisition target. Larger companies can purchase them and fold them into their business structure. At that point, the company will no longer be available for a small cap ETF fund manager to hold or purchase. This means that the greatest of small cap companies might not ever see a $2 billion price tag in the publicly traded markets. This also means that the ETF investor is no longer benefiting from the full potential growth to $2 billion of this hypothetically great company.
• There are a fair number of businesses in this space that are exploring speculative endeavors. The Russell 2000 is the de facto representation of small cap stocks and the iShares Russell 2000 ETF (
IWM) tracks it. Approximately 44% of this index is unprofitable, meaning that 880 companies are losing money. This lowers the overall P/E ratio. There are some ETFs that screen for profitability and limit this exposure such as the SPDR Portfolio S&P 600 Small Cap ETF (
SPSM). Pharmaceutical and energy exploration companies are good examples. A disproportionate number of pharmaceutical companies make up the Russell 2000 relative to other indices. These companies are looking for a breakthrough in order to be purchased by a larger company. They are willing to operate at a loss while looking for this breakthrough. The goal is an outsized reward for the outsized risk. A small cap ETF investor will not profit from this reward because the ETF fund manager will divest from the company when it surpasses the characteristics of a small cap company.
• Due to the failure rate of unprofitable companies, it is more prudent for a fund manager to spread the risk around and buy 600 to 2,000 small cap stocks. In aggregate, this dilutes the performance that great companies will earn for investors. Indices that track large cap companies domiciled in the United States are focused on significantly fewer investments, anywhere from 30 to 500.
Performance during 2020 pandemicTicker - Index - Constituents - Peak to Bottom - Bottom to Recovery - Peak to Bottom to Recovery
DIA - Dow Jones Industrials - 30 large companies in the United States across many sectors, excluding transportation and utilities - -36.1% - +48.1% - -5.3%
SPY - S&P 500 - 500 of the largest companies publicly traded in the United States - -33.4% - +50.6% - +0.2%
QQQ - Nasdaq 100 - 100 of the largest companies in the United States across many sectors, excluding financial services - -27.2% - +61.4% - +17.4%
IWM - Russell 2000 - 2,000 of the smallest companies in the Russell 3,000 - -40.8% - +55.0% - -8.3%
SPSM - S&P 600 Small Cap - 600 small cap companies in the United States - -41.7% - +51.7% - -11.5%
We found that the small cap ETFs, IWM and SPSM, performed the worst. They suffered significant losses and the volatile nature did not create greater performance during the recovery stage. Let's make sure we haven't cherry-picked the 2020 pandemic as our only comparative time period. By examining annualized performance over long time periods, we can see that small cap returns have not exceeded the indices of large caps. SPY and QQQ performed better over every single time period.
Annualized Long Term Tax Adjusted ReturnsTicker Symbol - 1 Year - 3 Year - 5 Year - 10 Year - 15 Year
DIA - +27.7% - -0.4% - +10.3% - +10.6% - +11.5%
SPY - +37.1% - +8.3% - +14.5% - +12.2% - +13.4%
QQQ - +38.5% - +8.3% - +17.5% - +18.6% - +20.0%
IWM - +31.3% - -0.6% - +7.9% - +7.4% - +10.5%
SPSM - +28.9% - -1.2% - +6.6% - +7.7% - +10.8%
Mathematically, if an investor experiences an investment loss of 10% then an 11% return is needed for the investment to reach its previous level. If an investor is down by 50%, then a return of 100% is needed to reach its previous level. The need for growth becomes exponentially larger. As a long-term investment, the data demonstrates that it is not realistic to hope that small cap ETFs can grow at a faster clip than similar large cap ETFs. We believe that maintaining a long-term investment in small cap ETFs is not the best approach. ETF investors are usually looking for professionals to create diversification with a solid basket of stocks to hang our hat on. Choosing the small cap stocks that will hopefully grow into large caps is not a reason conducive to investing in ETFs. A small cap investment could remain a laggard in one's portfolio without holding the higher growth potential the investor had hoped for during earlier investment choices. Small but great companies will grow and no longer be included in a small cap ETF. We believe that long-term investments in small cap ETFs are less desirable due to great companies facing an acquisition before reaching a $2 billion valuation, the volatility stemming from the speculative nature of certain small business models, and the mathematical truth that larger losses become exponentially harder to recover. While stock indices are at all-time highs, an investor could consider selling the small cap ETFs in their portfolio. Suitable replacements can be found in SPY or QQQ which track large cap indices in the United States and have better performance.