← Back to InvestProbability.com

Invest with tax efficiency

>Let's discuss tax efficient investing. Investors can use ETFs to manage their taxes better than using mutual funds. Everyone pays taxes, and there are different types: income tax, property tax, or the dreaded capital gains tax. Managing capital gains tax each year is one way we can exert some control over our tax burden. Tax laws can be complex, so let's simplify. The reason ETFs are typically more tax efficient than their mutual fund counterparts is due to capital gains taxes. At year end, a mutual fund investor will receive a payment in an unknown amount that represents the capital gains (profits) within the mutual fund. ETFs are structured differently and this capital gains distribution does not occur. An ETF issues shares when it is created. After an ETF issues shares, it is then bought and sold on an exchange by investors. When investors flock to a popular ETF, additional creation units are used to manage this influx of investors. This happens behind the scenes to retail investors. These creation units do not create a taxable event for investors in the ETF. The creation units are sold to broker-dealers and then sold on open exchanges as shares in the ETF. Structurally, this event is not happening inside the ETF and is not a taxable event to existing shareholders. When investors flock to a popular mutual fund, the mutual fund needs to buy enough assets to support this attention from investors. This also happens in reverse, when investors sell or "divest" from an unpopular mutual fund, the mutual fund needs to sell its assets to support the distributions to investors. This is not a decision based on the quality or timing of the assets in the mutual fund. When the mutual fund manager can sell the fund's assets for a net profit during the year, then a capital gains distribution is made to the fund's investors. This capital gains distribution is a taxable event for the investor. If the mutual fund manager needs to sell the fund's assets for a loss during the year, then the net asset value ("NAV"), or price of the mutual fund, decreases but is not a taxable event that lowers an investor's tax burden. When an ETF sells its assets, it is presumably based on the quality or timing of the assets in the ETF. As investors flock to a popular ETF or even "divest" from the ETF, these transactions are performed outside of the structural dynamics that value the ETF. Investor Jane sells shares to Investor Joe. There is no capital gain from this transaction inside the ETF. Therefore, an unknown amount of tax is not owed by Investor Charlie at year end. Investors can manage their taxes better by choosing ETFs instead of mutual funds at the onset of their investment.