>Isn't diversification supposed to protect an investment portfolio during stock market downturns? Risk parity strategies augment traditional Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) investment portfolios. A quick explanation of MPT is that investors own many asset classes in different allocation percentages based on the risk profile of the asset class. Unfortunately, the most common asset classes are different variations of stocks and bonds. This is limiting to investors who need to make strategic decisions during market downturns. Many investors have wanted to fund a major life event during a market downturn, but in order to do so, they'd have to sell their stocks and bonds at depressed prices. Many stock investors are taught to think about diversification as large/mid/small cap companies that are either domestic or international. Many investors are taught to think about bond diversification as sector, maturity, coupon and credit rating. There is an alternative and complimentary approach to MPT called risk parity strategies. A quick explanation of risk parity is that investors own uncorrelated asset classes to allocate risk more evenly. A reason for risk parity is that an investor could sell an uncorrelated asset when it isn't advantageous to sell their stocks or bonds. The technical definitions become convoluted very quickly. The methods of applying these concepts also vary widely. Let's start simplifying. There are correlated assets, inversely correlated assets, and uncorrelated assets. Correlated assets can be represented by the assumption that when large-cap stocks increase, mid-cap stocks also increase. Inversely correlated assets can be represented by a historical notion that when stock prices decrease, investors seek safety and bond prices increase. Uncorrelated assets can be represented by a commodity like crude oil which may increase, decrease, or trade sideways when the price of stocks increase. How does a long-term investor implement risk parity into their existing MPT portfolio? Let's simplify these concepts into a framework we can use. 1. Let's assume a portfolio is starting from 40% stocks and 60% bonds. This 40/60 allocation is usually considered to be seeking growth and income. We can use the iShares Core Moderate Allocation ETF (
AOM) to represent a Modern Portfolio Theory ETF. 2. Let's examine risk parity strategies by comparing AOM to an Risk Parity ETF (
RPAR).
Theoretical Allocation as applied within ETFsAsset Class - MPT - Risk Parity - MPT Ticker: AOM - RP Ticker: RPAR
Stocks
Large Cap U.S - 25% - 30% - 23% - 20%
Mid/Small Cap U.S. - 5% - 0% - 2% - 4%
International Developed Markets - 10% - 0% - 11% - 8%
International Emerging Markets - 0% - 0% - 0% - 5%
Fixed Income
U.S. Treasury Bonds - 50% - 40% - 20.5% - 70%
Corporate Bonds - 0% - 15% - 15.5% - 0%
Securitized Bonds - 0% - 0% - 11% - 0%
International Bonds - 10% - 0% - 9% - 0%
Uncorrelated Assets (examples)
Commodity Producers (Exxon, Deere) - 0% - 0% - 0% - 15%
Precious Metals (Gold, Silver) - 0% - 7% - 0% - 10%
Industrial Metals (Copper, Iron) - 0% - 2% - 0% - 0%
Soft Commodities (Wheat, Corn) - 0% - 2% - 0% - 0%
Energy (Oil, Gas) - 0% - 2% - 0% - 0%
Real Estate (REITs) - 0% - 2% - 0% - 0%
Leverage - 0% - 0% - 0% - (20%)
Long Cash - 0% - 0% - 0% - 15%
Short Cash - 0% - 0% - 0% - 35%
Upon examination, it is immediately apparent that RPAR is too complex to replicate. The allocation of 37% stocks / 70% bonds / 25% uncorrelated assets is achieved with leverage. Leverage is the use of borrowing against the value of securities in order to buy more than an account's market value. A common practice is for a custodian bank to allow an investor to hold 5x or 10x the account's market value in U.S. Treasury bonds, yet only 1.5x the account's market value in the stock of publicly-traded companies. This is likely the reason why RPAR demonstrates a complex approach to leverage. By staying focused on our goal, we can still implement risk parity. We are seeking a portfolio that is more dynamic than stocks and bonds in order to manage downturns. This can be achieved with uncorrelated assets. Here is an example portfolio that can be constructed:
A basic portfolio with Risk ParityAsset Class - Ticker - Expense Ratio - Allocation
Stocks
Large Cap U.S. - SPY - 0.09% - 30%
Fixed Income
Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index - AGG - 0.11% - 55%
Uncorrelated Assets
Gold - IAU - 0.25% - 7%
Industrial Metals (Copper, Iron) - DBB - 0.77% - 2%
Agricultural Commodities (Wheat, Corn) - DBA - 0.93% - 2%
Crude Oil - DBO - 0.77% - 2%
Real Estate (REITs) - VNQ - 0.12% - 2%
Weighted Expense Ratio - 0.157%
We have utilized a 30% allocation to SPY and a 55% allocation to AGG to represent stocks and bonds. See the first chapter to understand why we chose these two ETFs. We have allocated the remaining 15% of this portfolio to alternative asset classes that are deemed to be uncorrelated to stocks and bonds. We have created diversification by allocating 15% across precious metals (IAU), industrial metals (DBB), agricultural commodities (DBA), crude oil (DBO), and real estate (VNQ). These ETFs were chosen based on lower expense ratios than some of their competitors. We chose to use five commodity funds instead of a single fund that covers multiple commodities, so that each could be invested or divested from individually, based on market conditions and an investor's personal needs. We have achieved a portfolio based in Modern Portfolio Theory that utilizes Risk Parity strategies and sports a weighted expense ratio of 0.157%. Investors can decide when to sell these uncorrelated assets based on untimely downturns in the stock and bond markets intersecting with our important life events.