← Back to InvestProbability.com

Is Vietnam the new China?

>In terms of United States dollars (USD), would you prefer to earn $4 per year or $14,605 per year? In 2023, manufacturing jobs in Vietnam earned only $4 per year. Manufacturing jobs in China paid $14,605. What this means is that labor in Vietnam is much less expensive than labor in China. In contrast, manufacturing jobs in the United States paid approximately $52,000 per year at a rate of $26 per hour. The United States has outsourced manufacturing of the goods it consumes to China since the 1970s. Would it be advantageous for business owners in the United States to create a more resilient supply chain over its dependence on China? Let's dive deeper into the investable secular trend of Vietnamese manufacturing.

>Vietnam is growing faster than China or the United States. In Vietnam, manufacturing production increased 13.1% in September 2024 compared to the same month in 2023. Industrial production has grown at twice the speed as China over the same time period. Manufacturing is a process of creation, while industrials is a reference to manufacturing or a distribution of goods and services. It is important to look at both figures because they can be slightly interchangeable. The United States is still increasingly outsourcing its production in these two sectors of its economy.

Manufacturing and industrial production
Country - Growth of manufacturing production - Growth of industrial production
China - 5.2% - 5.4%
Vietnam - 13.1% - 10.8%
United States - -0.5% - -0.6%

Gross domestic product (GDP) is also a measurement of growth for countries in either real or nominal terms. Real GDP is an inflation-adjusted measure of all the goods and services a country produces. Vietnam is set to outpace China by growing real GDP by 6.1% this year and next. It is expected to hold the strongest growth of all emerging economies in Asia.

Real GDP Growth
Country - 2022 - 2023 - 2024 (projected) - 2025 (projected)
China - 3.0% - 5.2% - 5.3% - 5.0%
Vietnam - 8.1% - 5.0% - 6.1% - 6.1%

It is advantageous to utilize existing infrastructure when a business replaces a supplier. California holds extremely critical infrastructure for goods produced overseas. The Port of Long Beach and the Port of Los Angeles are the two largest and busiest ports in North America. Vietnam and China are so closely located to each other along the Pacific Ocean that a Vietnamese supply chain into California can be easily imagined. Business owners were affected when China created pandemic-related policies that effectively shut down its shipping ports that move goods into the United States. Supply chain disruptions, such as what occurred due to China's policies during and after 2020, typically involve shipping ports. Business owners could look at Vietnam for more resilience in their supply chain. Countries often place tariffs on goods that are strategic to their nation. Tariffs are a staple to the dynamic of the economic war between the United States and China. In the debate of Vietnamese versus Chinese manufacturing, business owners may prefer a more resilient supply chain. Maybe this is why a staggering percentage of foreign direct investments went into Vietnam versus China in August 2024. Vietnam is interesting because labor costs are less expensive in the manufacturing sector, its ability to grow real GDP, and its geographic location bordering China. Business owners in the United States could rely on the manufacturing of goods in a geographical location that leverages similar supply chain logistics that began in the 1970s. This confluence of factors has translated into the stock of companies domiciled in Vietnam growing year-to-date (YTD) in 2024 at the same pace as China.

Stock Market YTD
Country - YTD Returns (Jan 1, 2024 - Sep 30, 2024)
China - 10.9%
Vietnam - 10.9%

This is an opportunity to diversify one's investments into global economies that are defensive and still growing. In the world of ETF investing, there are two ETFs that focus on equity stakes in Vietnamese companies. These ETFs hold a larger concentration in the consumer defensive and industrials sectors relative to the S&P 500 (SPY).

Investing in Vietnam
Ticker - Fund (ETF) Name - PE Ratio - Two largest sector allocations
VNAM - Global X MSCI Vietnam - 11.1 - 10% Consumer Defensive / 15% Industrials
VNM - VanEck Vietnam - 14.1 - 25% Consumer Defensive / 30% Industrials

It is always imperative for ETF investors to understand what the underlying investments are. The two ETFs that take equity stakes in Vietnamese companies are invested in the following businesses:

Top holdings of the funds examined
Company Name - Business - VNAM - VNM
Hoa Phat Group - Steel production and trading - 10.5% - 6.8%
Vinhomes - Real estate development - 8.4% - 5.2%
Joint Stock Commercial Bank for Foreign Trade of Vietnam - Financial services - 6.5% - 6.1%
Ma San Group - Food and beverage conglomerate - 6.4% - 0%
Vietnam Dairy Products - Milk and dairy products - 6.3% - 6.2%
Vingroup - Real estate construction - 6.1% - 7.5%
SSI Securities - Investment banking - 4.3% - 5.4%
Duc Giang Chemicals - Chemicals manufacturing - 2.6% - 2.8%
Masan Consumer - Food product manufacturing - 0% - 1.2%
Vndirect Securities - Brokerage and finance consulting - 2.1% - 3.5%
Vietcap Securities - Brokerage and securities investment services - 0% - 2.9%

Vietnam is still an emerging economy. An ETF investor comfortable with the risks of investing in emerging economies could consider the manufacturing growth of Vietnam outpacing China. The VanEck Vietnam ETF (VNM) is much larger in terms of total assets. It is slightly more expensive and the trade-off is gained by a larger investment in consumer defensive products. VNM could be seen as a safer choice for the long-term growth of Vietnam in the lucrative supply chain that feeds the United States.