>Saturday, the Finance Minister of China failed to unleash an expected $280 billion stimulus package. Should investors look at this as an opportunity to buy Chinese equities at lower prices? Or is there an alternative? China has been on a long road of securing global superpower status. In 2012, China's leader, President Xi Jinping took office and has been straggling every corner of the People's Republic of China into a stronger position both militarily and economically. His authoritarian rule has few boundaries, having even skipped succession plans by not stepping out of office after the standard two 5-year terms. There are expectations that he may stay in power for life. China is a Communist country. Communism, in terms of the People's Republic of China, is defined as 'a totalitarian system of government in which a single authoritarian party controls state-owned means of production'. It is also defined as 'a final stage of society in Marxist theory in which the state has withered away and economic goods are distributed equally'.>But is China withering away? One could think not, with its increasing military strength and the economic strength found in China's reserves of rare earth minerals. Militarily, China has bested the United States in being first to develop a hypersonic missile. Hypersonic missiles are maneuverable weapon systems that travel at 5x the speed of sound. They are not possible to defeat with today's defensive systems. Economically, China commands 60% of the world's rare earth minerals. Rare earth minerals are critical to 21st century technological advancements. Semiconductors, electric vehicles, and hypersonic missiles all need rare earth minerals. On the other hand, one could think that China is withering away. In 2021, the Chinese government cracked down on the education sector. It banned for-profit tutoring on core school subjects. The sudden change created a massive disruption to the $100 billion sector. This caused a heavy drag on China's overall equity market valuation and an abrupt change in the investment thesis for foreign investors. In September of 2024, the Chinese government announced wide sweeping stimulus. They intend to deploy the largest economic intervention since the pandemic, in order to pull China out of its deflationary woes. This news had a profound impact. Chinese equity markets recently shot up 25% over five trading days. What is an investor to do with all of this information?>Is there a safer alternative to Mainland China for investors looking for an emerging market ETF? We can analyze the ETFs that specifically invest in Mainland China: the KraneShares CSI China Internet ETF (
KWEB) and the Invesco China Technology ETF (
CQQQ). We can compare the characteristics of KWEB and CQQQ to the ETF that invests in Taiwan, the iShares MSCI Taiwan ETF (
EWT).
Investing in Mainland China vs. TaiwanTicker - Location - Expense Ratio - PE Ratio
KWEB - Mainland China - 0.69% - 20.6
CQQQ - Mainland China - 0.70% - 19.3
EWT - Taiwan - 0.59% - 17.5
Top holdings of the funds examinedCompany Name - Business - KWEB - CQQQ
Tencent Holdings - Social networking, music, portals, e-commerce, mobile games - 10.3% - 10.1%
Alibaba - E-commerce, retail, internet, and technology - 9.8% - 0%
Meituan - Shopping platform for locally found consumer products and retail services - 8.3% - 9.6%
BYD - New energy vehicles - 0% - 8.1%
Bank of China - Central bank and international financial services - 0% - 0%
Industrial and Commercial Bank of China - Corporate and retail banking - 0% - 0%
PDD Holdings - Moves multinational commerce into the digital economy - 6.8% - 8.6%
KE Holdings - Residential real estate - 4.7% - 0%
Trip.com Group - Online travel agency - 4.0% - 0%
Baidu - Internet search engine - 3.0% - 6.3%
Vipshop Holdings - Online discount retailer - 0% - 0%
Full Truck Alliance - Freight matching services for shippers and truckers - 3.6% - 0%
Kuaishou Technology - Social media platform - 0% - 5.5%
Bilibili - Online entertainment - 0% - 4.3%
SenseTime Group - AI-empowered software and hardware - 0% - 3.8%
Sunny Optical Technology - Handset cameras, lens and AR/VR - 0% - 3.8%
The Mainland China ETFs hold companies in sectors such as financial services that traditionally have lower PE ratios than advanced technology companies. A PE ratio is the multiple an investor will pay for future earnings. Investors do pay more for the future growth that secular trends such as the world's need for semiconductors could promise over slower growing businesses. This shows up in the higher PE ratios of KWEB and CQQQ, which focus on internet, technology and communication services companies. By understanding all the variables, we are comfortable with the investment thesis of Taiwan over Mainland China. Investors can sleep well at night with the safer choice being EWT.