← Back to InvestProbability.com

Rotating into defense

>Is there a way to protect a portfolio from all the turmoil in the world these days? Are the traditional defensive moves investors make still viable? Gold is already at all-time highs and the Federal Reserve is decreasing the yield on bonds in the United States. Since its inception, even the traditionally defensive Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLP) has reached its highest price just last month. There are humanitarian crises, military operations, wars, airstrikes and cyber-attacks in the world seemingly every day. Maybe we could look at being defensive from a different lens. Maybe the defense industry could protect our investment portfolios from these global risks. The defense industry includes companies such as Lockheed Martin (LMT) and GE Aerospace (GE). These companies derive most of their revenue from government contracts. Let's look at some numbers in order to understand the scale of this industry. The National Defense Authorization Act has approved $911.8 billion in spending for fiscal year 2025. A full 73% of Lockheed Martin's revenue comes from the U.S. government. Lockheed Martin's expectations for revenue in 2024 is approximately $71 billion. This equates to LMT receiving almost 8% of the U.S. government's defense spending. It is reasonable to believe that LMT is undervalued. LMT currently has a PE ratio, based on the last twelve months, of just 20.2. A PE ratio tells investors exactly what they are paying for every $1 of earnings the company makes. LMT is relatively inexpensive for investors compared to the broader market valuation of SPY, which carries a 27.2 PE ratio. How do we take advantage of an undervalued defense contractor industry? ETF investors can accomplish this by allocating towards a defense industry ETF. We have included an examination of these four largest and most actively traded defense ETFs below.

Selecting the Right Defense ETF
Ticker - Fund (ETF) Name - Net Assets - Expense Ratio - Number of holdings - Largest 3 holdings (%) - 10-Year Annualized Return
ITA - iShares U.S. Aerospace & Defense - $6.4 billion - 0.40% - 35 - 47.9% - 9.1%
PPA - Invesco Aerospace & Defense - $3.7 billion - 0.57% - 55 - 20.6% - 14.3%
SHLD - Global X Defense Tech - $400 million - 0.50% - 34 - 15.6% - N/A
ARKX - ARK Space Exploration & Innovation - $200 million - 0.75% - 34 - 23.4% - N/A

ITA holds 35 equities with the 3 largest making up almost half of its portfolio. If an investor is to use an ETF product for diversification, they generally do not want to be so concentrated in their top holdings. We want to rule out ITA due to the reliance on three companies making up roughly half of the fund. PPA and SHLD are reasonably structured with less than 10% invested in any one company. SHLD has a lower expense ratio than PPA, but PPA has proven itself with annualized returns of 14.3% over the past 10 years. We want to rule out SHLD because it is too young still, with an inception date last year. An investor could keep it on their watchlist. With the exception for ARKX, each of these ETFs are generally invested in the same companies. Its sole focus on the growing space industry is narrower than its peers. ARKX only has 23% invested in large cap companies. We want to rule out ARKX for this reason. PPA currently holds 55 equities with the largest holdings kept in check under 8% each. An investor would be paying a slightly higher expense ratio for PPA and will receive a slightly lower average PE ratio. It has a stated investment strategy indicating investments in '...stocks of companies that are systematically important to the defense sector...' We believe that the management team at PPA understands the importance of investing in companies most likely to win major government contracts. There is less risk that a single company will decide the fate for ETF investors that are seeking the relative safety found in a basket of stocks. It is PPA for the win!