← Back to InvestProbability.com

Rotating into health care

>For investors that believe we are heading towards lower prices in the stock market, preparing for the next sector rotation could be beneficial. The health care sector is a defensive sector. Consumers are likely to spend a similar amount of money on their health care in recessions as expansions. We believe in being prepared for downturns rather than reacting to them. It is best to stay emotionally neutral when we invest. We are proposing that a good preparation will be to have already chosen an investment for the health care sector. Last week we discussed a sector rotation into the utilities sector as a defensive position against a possible recession. How defensive should we be?

>Warren Buffett, CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, is endearingly named the Oracle of Omaha for his investing prowess. His latest 10-Q SEC filing showed he cut Berkshire's stake in Apple in half from $174.3 billion to $84.2 billion over the first 6 months of 2024. Does this mean the Oracle of Omaha is becoming more defensive by selling shares in Apple, a mega-cap technology company? Berkshire Hathaway's top 5 holdings accounted for 79% of its assets before the Apple shares were sold. Afterwards, the top 5 holdings still accounted for 72% of Berkshire Hathaway's assets. This is a large concentration by any measure.

Quantifying the Healthcare Sector ETFs
Ticker - Fund (ETF) Name - P/E Ratio - Dividend Yield (SEC) - Alpha - 10-Year Annualized Tax Adjusted Returns
RSPH - Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight Health Care - 18.4 - 0.70% - -3.86 - 10.1%
FHLC - Fidelity MSCI Health Care - 20.9 - 1.36% - -1.26 - 10.4%
VHT - Vanguard Health Care - 20.4 - 1.35% - -1.26 - 10.6%
IXJ - iShares Global Healthcare - 20.8 - 1.27% - -0.02 - 8.7%
IYH - iShares US Healthcare - 21.3 - 1.14% - -0.58 - 10.4%
XLV - The Health Care Select Sector SPDR - 20.9 - 1.53% - 0.87 - 10.5%

The Health Care Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLV) is the only member of this group that generates positive Alpha. Alpha is the excess returns an ETF makes relative to the risk taken. A positive Alpha tells an investor that the fund is doing well. It is achieving performance returns with its investment decisions, without taking outsized risk. IYH is too expensive relative to its peers.