← Back to InvestProbability.com

Is it time to sell covered calls?

>A quadrillion dollars! Some estimates have the size of the derivatives market to be a quadrillion dollars. To put this into perspective, the size of the global stock market is a mere $115 trillion. The size of the global bond market is higher at $141 trillion. Is there a safe way to gain access to the derivatives market?

>Options contracts are one type of derivative. They represent the value of 100 shares of stock or ETFs. Options contracts are divided into two types, calls and puts. A covered call is a strategy that involves buying stock (or an ETF) and selling a call options contract. A call option gives the buyer the opportunity to purchase shares from the seller if they choose to.

>Investors can use covered call strategies to generate additional income for a traditional stock and bond portfolio. Investors can do this themselves, or invest in ETFs that implement covered call strategies. These ETFs are helpful when an investor is constrained by time or capital. Before investing in them, it's important to understand what one would be owning.

>The buyer of an option pays the seller a price for the options contract, which is called a premium. The seller generates additional income by collecting the premium received from the call option. A seller needs to hold 100 shares as a form of collateral for a covered call. A "covered" call means that the shares are owned by the seller. In contrast, there are "naked" calls, where the seller does not own the underlying shares. This creates substantial risk because the seller is still obligated to deliver shares they do not own, potentially at an extremely high cost if the stock price surges.

>It can be expensive and time consuming to do this by oneself. Instead, let's examine ETFs based on an index of stocks. The first table focuses on the Nasdaq 100 index, which represents large technology companies. The second table focuses on the S&P 500 index, which represents a broader swath of the U.S. economy.

Nasdaq 100 covered call strategies
Ticker Symbol - Index - Expense Ratio - 12-Month Dividend Yield - 12-Month Price Return - 12-Month Total Return - Covered Call
QYLD - Nasdaq 100 - 0.61% - 11.51% - -3.53% - 8.28% - Yes
QQQ - Nasdaq 100 - 0.20% - 0.61% - 31.95% - 32.74% - No
S&P 500 covered call strategies
Ticker Symbol - Index - Expense Ratio - 12-Month Dividend Yield - 12-Month Price Return - 12-Month Total Return - Covered Call
XYLD - S&P 500 - 0.60% - 9.26% - 0.45% - 9.71% - Yes
JEPI - S&P 500 - 0.35% - 7.02% - 4.49% - 11.51% - Yes
SPY - S&P 500 - 0.09% - 1.21% - 20.28% - 21.49% - No

Using the last 12 months as a gauge, investors in covered call ETFs received a higher yield (dividends) for less price return. They also paid a higher expense ratio to buy into the covered call ETFs. Does this investment still make sense? Well, maybe. Covered call strategies are not as effective in markets that are extremely bullish. Investors are long stocks by owning the shares (bullish). They are also short stocks by selling the call option (bearish). The call option is generating income but it is also dragging on total returns by adding a bearish position in extremely bullish markets. These two indices are at all-time highs. It might very well be time to hedge a long stock portfolio by selling some high-fliers and re-allocating into covered call strategy ETFs.