← Back to InvestProbability.com

Replace your target-date fund

>Target-date funds are built for ease and simplicity, but is there an alternative? Target-date funds change their investment allocations based on time. Target date funds are intended to appeal to the "set it and forget it" crowd. Invest and then retire in the year of the target date. Investors considering retirement 20 years from now might select a fund targeting the year 2045. As 2045 approaches, the fund shifts its investments to be more conservative: less stocks and more bonds. A 2024 CNBC report states that, "A record-high 64% of all 2023 [401k] contributions went into target-date funds, which automatically adjust stock and bond allocations as the participant ages." What happens if an investor's needs don't line up with this predetermined outcome? How does an investor create a similar structure with more control? Is there a better way than following the classic mold of 60% stocks and 40% bonds and entering retirement with a bond portfolio? Are we investing well enough to choose a mutual fund 20 years before retirement age? We intend to provide an alternative framework. Is ease and simplicity enough to ignore market movements, tactical allocations, and your personal progress towards your retirement? It is perfectly okay that 64% of 401k investors said yes in 2023. This is a framework for investors wanting to take control of their financial wellness. We can examine this concept comparatively, by referencing ITDE, the iShares LifePath Target Date 2045 ETF (exchange-traded fund). It has a current allocation of 58% U.S. equities, 30% international equities and 10% in bonds. The expense ratio is 0.11%. The underlying holdings are 13 funds spanning 29,610 investments.

A typical target date fund
Ticker - Name - Weighting - Asset Class
IWB - iShares Russell 1000 ETF - 51.4% - U.S. Large Cap Blend
IDEV - iShares Core MSCI Int'l Developed ETF - 21.7% - Developed Markets Large Cap Blend
IEMG - iShares Core MSCI Emerging Markets ETF - 8.9% - Emerging Markets Large Cap Blend
USRT - iShares Core US REIT ETF - 4.2% - Real Estate Investment Trusts
IGLB - iShares 10 YR Inv Grade Corp Bond ETF - 4.2% - Corporate Bonds
MBB - iShares MBS ETF - 3.2% - Mortgage Backed Securities
IWM - iShares Russell 2000 ETF - 2.7% - U.S. Small Cap Blend
TLH - iShares 10-20 YR Treasury Bond ETF - 1.5% - U.S. Treasury Bonds
GOVT - iShares US Treasury Bond ETF - 1.1% - U.S. Treasury Bonds
IGSB - iShares 1-5 YR Inv Grade Corp Bond ETF - 0.7% - Corporate Bonds
IGIB - iShares 5-10 YR Inv Grade Corp Bond ETF - 0.5% - Corporate Bonds

Our goal is a safe retirement and investors do not need to be experts in every asset class that ITDE invests in. These asset classes include large and small domestic stocks, international stocks in both developed and emerging markets, Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS), and Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs). The basis for our simplified framework are the two largest and safest asset classes: large cap stocks domiciled in the United States and investment grade bonds. We can invest directly into the most common benchmark indices used by professional wealth managers: the S&P 500 (U.S. large cap stocks) and the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index (investment grade bonds). This article is going to emphasize investing efficiently. We will challenge the need for investing in international companies of developed and emerging markets. We are more comfortable with investments we understand. The common pitch for diversification has stretched into owning every available asset class. We are claiming that this is unnecessary. For example, if 20 years prior to retirement, how does an investor understand the potential reward from a 3.2% investment allocation to Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS)? Let's choose to be efficient with our investments and utilize every dollar intentionally. Let's choose to place that 3.2% into the stocks and bonds that we understand. We can assume historical averages to represent expected returns, which are 10% annualized growth of stocks and 6% annualized growth of bonds. These assumptions can be realized when we invest in the asset classes they represent: the S&P 500 (U.S. large cap stocks) and the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index (investment grade bonds). We lose focus when we are afraid of missing out on returns from each and every asset class. The S&P 500 is the gold standard to measure the performance of the stock components in an investment portfolio. The S&P 500 is an index of 500 large-cap companies domiciled in the United States. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) is a way to passively track its performance in an investment account. The expense ratio of SPY is quite reasonable at 0.09%. The companies in the S&P 500 generate 41% of their revenue from overseas. There are long held beliefs in the financial industry that investors need to own international stocks for diversification. After decades of industrial globalization, investors have plenty of international exposure, more familiarity, less geopolitical risk and less currency risk by utilizing the S&P 500. We are asserting that not all retirement investors need to own mid-cap and small-cap companies. The example target date fund, ITDE, happens to invest 2.7% in mid/small-capitalization companies via the Russell 2000 (IWM). IWM is spread across 1,934 holdings with a 6% allocation to mid-cap companies, 55% to small-caps and 38% to micro-caps. These companies have not created a large-cap market valuation. Investors are not missing out on "the next big thing" because their returns are diluted by the other 1,933 companies in the index. Instead, let's be patient and wait for the most successful companies to be included in the S&P 500. Companies valued over $10 billion are large-cap companies. The most successful companies in the world are valued over $1 trillion. This provides plenty of room for the potential growth of large-cap stocks. The Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index is the gold standard for investment grade bond investors. The iShares Core US Aggregate Bond ETF (AGG) has tracked its performance since 2003. AGG boasts a 0.03% expense ratio, an average credit quality of AA-, and an effective duration of 6.01 years. The SEC Yield or 30-day yield is currently 4.6%. Asset allocations to SPY (0.09%) and AGG (0.03%) have a lower expense ratio than the expense ratio found in ITDE (0.11%). An asset allocation of SPY and AGG can be used by investors to represent the most common benchmark indices used by institutional investors. The allocation percentages could be changed based on the investor's personal life events. We do have careers that fluctuate in income, yet we still need to pay for expenses, such as housing, medical, and/or educational needs. These needs are not factored into a target date fund as it changes its asset allocation based on time instead of an investor's life events. A worthwhile service to support your own financial wellness is to review your needs and progress routinely. You can perform a financial wellness review by yourself, with family or with a professional. This review can be the basis for your allocation to stocks and bonds. Decide on your asset allocation in relation to your life's expenses and the growth of your investments. Take control of your investments by reviewing your asset allocation periodically and by investing in a simplified yet diversified allocation of SPY and AGG.